The film Perfect had all the ingredients for success—a star-studded cast, a respected director, a hefty budget, and a subject that tapped into the fitness craze of the 1980s. Yet, despite all these elements, it became one of Hollywood’s biggest flops, leaving audiences and critics alike baffled.

John Travolta and Jamie Lee Curtis were at the height of their careers when they were cast in Perfect in 1985. Travolta had already solidified his status as a cultural icon with hits like Saturday Night Fever and Grease, while Curtis had carved a niche for herself as both a horror queen and a rising A-list actress. Columbia Pictures poured a whopping $20 million into the production, an enormous sum for the time. With James Bridges directing—best known for The China Syndrome—expectations were high. Yet, upon its release, the film struggled at the box office, earning only $12.9 million worldwide.

Adding insult to injury, Perfect was nominated for three Golden Raspberry Awards, including Worst Actor (Travolta), Worst Supporting Actress (Marilu Henner), and Worst Screenplay. It even received a nod for Worst Picture at the infamous Stinkers Bad Movie Awards. The film, which followed journalist Adam Lawrence (Travolta) as he investigated fitness clubs and fell for aerobics instructor Jessie Wilson (Curtis), was intended to capture the pulse of a fitness-obsessed generation. Instead, it became a textbook case of how a film can go terribly wrong.

Many critics were baffled by the execution. The film was filled with awkward creative choices, from overly stylized workout sequences to questionable dialogue. Travolta’s revealing gym shorts became an unintentional talking point, and the aerobic class sequences—which involved an excessive number of pelvic thrusts—bordered on comical. For some, it was impossible to take the film seriously. The New York Times summed it up by saying that Perfect was “one of the most unintentionally campy films of the decade.”